The Pay Cut Nobody Mentions

Your headline pay goes up. Your take-home pay can go down. Here’s where the money goes, and how to be ready.

I started my legal career thinking law was a path to great wealth. Inside a firm, I learned it can be (certainly more than the bank teller salary my family lived on for years while I grew up). But often, it isn’t. Equity partnership offers a very comfortable life, but most partners aren’t swimming in gold coins like Scrooge McDuck. That’s the clients. It’s how they afford $1,000+/hour attorneys in the first place.

Around the time I realized this, I heard a bogus-sounding rumor that made me even more skeptical of law firm partnership as an unqualified financial bonanza. In your first year as a partner, you can make less than you did in your last year as an associate. That’s not an urban legend. It’s true.

When transitioning to equity partner status, money vanishes before your very eyes by flowing into four buckets: capital contributions (buying in), self-employment tax, lost employee benefits and new out-of-pocket costs, and estimated taxes. Likely, you’ll look richer on paper than you feel.

The root cause of the outflows? You’re a business owner now. And these changes, from worker to owner, are not unique to law. Indeed, each one, even the capital contribution (in its own way), applies to me as a wealth management firm founder. I’ve been running my own business for a few years, and I wouldn’t trade the upside and flexibility for anything. But even though owning a business is fulfilling and empowering, you should understand and prepare for certain speed bumps as you transition to ownership.

Capital contribution

At a law firm, your capital contribution funds the firm’s operations. It covers expenses and capital spending, and it also cushions lean times. The amount of capital your firm will expect you to contribute is often in the hundreds of thousands of dollars. As I’ve written about elsewhere, this is a big financial lift that hits you right when life gets expensive on other fronts.

Since few new partners can pay this amount upfront without family help or exceptionally diligent saving, firms usually arrange bank loans repaid over 3 to 10 years. Sometimes the firm covers the interest. Firms also commonly hold back 10–20% of your distributions in the early years until your capital account is fully funded.

You might think your capital contribution would be a deductible business expense—a huge tax advantage—but it isn’t. It’s equity on your balance sheet that you’ll get back when you leave or retire.

Mechanics and specifics aside, here’s a big question a hefty capital contribution should prompt: when buying into a law firm, what am I actually buying? Experience has taught me to be leery of businesses whose only real assets get on the elevator and go home every night.

I’m not saying you shouldn’t accept partnership just because firms rely heavily on human capital; most established law partnerships will run just fine. But they can be among the most fragile businesses to own. It’s startling how quickly a seemingly perfectly healthy law firm can find itself fighting to survive after key partners defect. Weil’s move to wind down is an extreme example. As shockingly fast as it unfolded, it was foreseeable, on some level, in an era of partner musical chairs. If it can happen to Weil, it can happen almost anywhere. Be ready. Know the culture and structure you’re buying before it’s time to write a big check.

Self-employment tax

As a partner, you lose the W-2 employee’s FICA withholding and instead pay self-employment tax on your earnings. You cover both the employee and employer shares, which means you pay 12.4% in Social Security tax up to the annual wage base. You also pay 2.9% for Medicare on all earnings, and an extra 0.9% Medicare tax on your earnings above $200,000 (single) or $250,000 (married filing jointly).

Small firm partners can hold their partnership interest through a personal Professional Corporation (PC) or professional LLC that elects S-Corporation status. This lets you split your income into a reasonable salary and S-corporation distributions. The former is subject to payroll taxes; the latter is not. This pivot can reduce your self-employment tax bill, and it’s a smart tactic—when it’s available. In large firms, this arrangement is usually not feasible.

Lost employee benefits and new expenses

When you graduate to equity partner, the firm stops subsidizing your benefits. In particular, you now pay the employer’s share of your health care premiums, and life and disability coverage, along with fringe benefits, become out-of-pocket or taxable expenses. Plus, you no longer get a 401(k) match. What probably felt like free stuff for years now becomes your (expensive, not to mention boring) responsibility.

Nonetheless, business owners have great retirement plan options. You lose free money in the form of an employer match, but you gain far more room to shelter your own. For example, I can reliably contribute to my Roth Solo 401(k) as both employee and employer every year. I save far more in tax-advantaged ways than I could as a W-2 employee. I understand the cash balance plan’s appeal—massive savings—and will set one up when it makes sense. Healthcare is the exception. At a big firm, you’ll likely stay on the group plan and simply pay the full premium. As a solo owner, I haven’t found a great answer, so for now we’re happy to use my wife’s insurance.

Cash flow timing and estimated taxes

Partnership replaces steady paychecks and W-2 withholding with variable income and no withholding. Rather than salary, you take draws against expected profits, plus quarterly or year-end distributions, and pay estimated taxes quarterly. In year one, paying 110% of last year’s tax allows you to avoid underpayment penalties. But the safe harbor only spares you the penalty. You still owe the full bill in April, so make sure you save for it. (I’ve written more about managing your cash as a law firm partner here.)

I make quarterly payments in my business. I can attest that, with a good accountant’s help, they’re easy. But first things first, you need to find yourself a good accountant. And then, as busy as you are, there’s a chance you forget something important in the early stages. For example, make sure your auto-debit to the IRS comes from the account you intend, and that account is sufficiently funded by the deadline.

Promoted, not poorer

None of this makes partnership a bad deal. It just makes the first year more turbulent if you’re not careful. Your money changes form more than it disappears, with your capital coming back when you leave, assuming the firm is still around to return it. And you can shelter far more for retirement than a match ever gave you. Quarterly estimates, meanwhile, become routine by about the third time you pay them. So, this can be a smooth transition if you plan. Keep a fat cash cushion for the first year and hire the accountant before you need one. Scrooge McDuck doesn’t seem like the type of guy who filled his coffers by assuming things would sort themselves out. You shouldn’t either.

Next
Next

Variable Income Punishes Fixed Bad Habits